Is Apple’s vision for XR really pro?

We live in an era where technology is constantly evolving and changing. However, the development and hype around VR/AR has stalled over the past year. I’m sure I wasn’t the only one surprised by the timing of Apple’s entry into VR and AR. If their headset had been released a year ago, the hype would have been enormous. But why has interest in the virtual world waned? My theory is that we are held back by our limited view of what the technology could actually be. VR (Virtual Reality), AR (Augmented Reality), and spatial computing are some of the most exciting recent developments. These technologies offer a whole new level of interaction and experience, and have the potential to revolutionize everything from entertainment to education and work.

But are we really ready for the digital experience that AR is capable of? Do we truly understand what immersive computer experiences should be? The technology is fantastic, but the VR/AR experience is still stuck in a 2D-based screen mindset. Now that we can finally use our environment as an augmented reality, we are content to simply fill it with 2D windows.

Examples from Apple's AR user experience primarily consisted of 2D objects.
Examples from Apple’s AR user experience primarily consisted of 2D objects.

Despite the incredible technology embedded in Apple Vision Pro, examples from Apple’s user experience primarily consist of 2D objects placed in the AR environment. Pictures, PDFs, Excel sheets, and websites are just displayed as slabs here and there. We need to think bigger. Think differently! In a true immersive experience, we should be able to enter and engage with data in a completely new way that can only be experienced in the virtual world. A website should be a digital house that we walk into, for example. A movie should be a 360-experience where I become part of the adventure. With the help of AI generation, the adventure could be different every time I participate, note the choice of word, in the film.

An immersive experience is about shifting from observing to participating.

My son, an avid gamer, often plays VR games. When he puts on the VR headset, he is transported to a completely new world. He can explore this world, interact with objects and characters in it, and even feel the sensation of actually being there. This is the power of VR – the ability to create such an immersive experience that the boundary between the virtual and the real world blurs.

I recently talked to my son about how we used to watch movies on VHS tapes. I described to him how we used to go to a box or a shelf, pick a tape, and feed it into a VHS player to watch a movie. His first comment was: “Wow, that’s how YouTube should be in the Oculus headset!” And I could only agree.

When brave museums step into virtual experiences, they unfortunately rarely aim high. Instead of creating something that cannot otherwise be experienced, it is common to see solutions that aim to recreate the museum visit in VR. Yawn. Imagine visiting ancient Rome and conversing with an ancient Roman citizens, and perhaps visiting the Colosseum together. Nope, instead, all we get to see is a statue, in a hallway, with text on a sign.

A VR experience within a museum rarely leaves the user in awe.

I believe that the best inspiration for future AR apps, even for the workplace, should come from VR games and gamification. Such games as RecRoom, Roblox, and others. Here are fantastic examples of how surfaces, objects, buttons, and environments are used to create something that is not possible anywhere else. Another good example is the game Floorplan where the “menu navigation” is in the form of a backpack that you pull out.

But as with all new technologies, there are challenges. One of the biggest is creating a user experience that is both intuitive and engaging. This is especially important for VR and AR, where the quality of the experience directly influences the user’s willingness to continue using the technology and choose it over the old usual way. There are also issues of privacy and security, especially when it comes to collecting and using data from these devices.

Despite these challenges, the potential for VR, AR, and spatial computing is enormous. With the right approach and by taking into account the needs and concerns of users, these technologies can create truly transformative experiences. And perhaps most importantly, they can help us to see and interact with the world in new and exciting ways.

However, we must remember that we should not just fill our augmented reality with “more of the same”. To truly understand the power of VR, AR, and spatial computing, we must be willing to think in new ways, and challenge our preconceived notions. Let’s curiously explore what these technologies can offer.

Johan Leidefors

Johan Leidefors

Experience Designer at Sogeti

I am passionate about emerging technologies and consider myself a professional early adopter. Eager to explore new and innovative ways to improve the user experience and drive business goals. Currently, I am particularly interested in the possibilities of AI-generated content and XR (extended reality) technology.

Contact me today!

Full CV on Notion

Check out my portfolio designs

All the other posts from the Tech Blog

The way we use AI will determine it’s potential

The way we use AI will determine it’s potential

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has revolutionized the way we work and interact with technology. Its potential is vast, offering value across various sectors. However, to truly tap into AI’s potential, we need to shift our focus from pure technology to the user experience (UX). By designing how users interact with AI in specific contexts, AI can become a powerful tool that adds value and simplifies our lives.

Ai(m) for the stars

Ai(m) for the stars

Changing Perspective. AI should be the "rocket fuel" that takes the humans to the stars, not replacing the astronauts. 🚀💫 As some of you have understood I've been reflecting on how we perceive AI these days, and I wanted to share some thoughts with you. I'm the first...

The AI Conundrum: Efficiency vs. Employment

The AI Conundrum: Efficiency vs. Employment

AI's unlimited potential has raised concerns about unemployment, as AI-enabled systems may outperform and replace humans in many job roles. This poses a pressing question... How do we strike a balance between ultra-efficient work through AI and the potential job...

Come on kids, let me tell you about life before AI!

Come on kids, let me tell you about life before AI!

Just as my Millennial generation (and older) recalls a life before the internet, future generations will reminisce about a time when AI wasn't an integral part of their daily lives. It's astounding to think about how much the world has changed since the advent of the...

The contradiction in Ai development

The contradiction in Ai development

When AI becomes competent enough to produce a finished product from a simple input prompt, does this render the need for that product obsolete? Perhaps. Let me explain… As I gaze into the metaphorical crystal ball, read guess, attempting to predict the ever-evolving...

AI is disrupting our content driven platforms – more than you know

AI is disrupting our content driven platforms – more than you know

AI has come a long way in recent years, and one of the most exciting applications of this technology is the ability to generate images and text. Using techniques like deep learning, AI algorithms can analyze vast amounts of data and create original content that can be...

Embracing AI: Your Digital Colleague

Embracing AI: Your Digital Colleague

Don't worry, AI is here to help, not replace you. Find comfort in knowing that your creativity and humanity will always have a place in the world of work. AI has the potential to revolutionize the way we work, and I can sense the concern creeping up on some of you:...

The Inevitable Clash of Digital Titans

The Inevitable Clash of Digital Titans

Google might just have met its match in AI technology. Will it become the new Nokia of the digital world? Remember the days when Nokia was the king of the mobile phone industry? One couldn't walk down the street without seeing a Nokia phone in someone's hand. And...

Shaping the Digital Society of Tomorrow

Shaping the Digital Society of Tomorrow

In a virtual world where anything is possible, the design of our digital reality should be driven by people's participation and human potential – not just the potential of technology. As we embark on a journey into the realms of mixed reality, augmented reality (AR),...